Oct 15, 2020

Turbulent Equilibrium

Big whorls have little whorls 
Which feed on their velocity, 
And little whorls have lesser whorls 
And so on to viscosity.

Self-perception can be interesting. The idea that you conceive of yourself to be a certain way is fascinating to me. And more than that, with all our cognitive biases and skewed perceptions, a lot of self-perception is actually incorrect. This incorrectness too is not necessarily a flaw - it can be merely an evolutionary short-cut towards efficiency. After all, we are made to survive, not to be optimum observers of objective reality as it is. 

Mindfulness is an idea that has rather captured me ever since I heard of it. To be mindful, sthitha prajna (ಸ್ಥಿತ ಪ್ರಜ್ಞ) as my father repeated over and over during my childhood, is an ideal that has always drawn me in. I have never actually taken any deliberate or organised steps towards becoming mindful but once I read about the concept and it became an ideal, I felt that it was a quality that I was imbibing, almost on auto-pilot. The knowledge of something, the act of giving something a name, can be powerful. For example, "mansplaining". You don't necessarily conceive of it on our own, but once you learn the word, you start seeing it often. 

Similarly I felt that my own state of mind and behaviour was titlting towards mindfulness. But alas, it was only self-perception. 

Let me take a small detour into turbulence. Not the kind that plays pinball with aircrafts. Well that is turbulence, but I mean it in a more general, physicsy sense. Turbulence is very precisely defined by physicists as "that kind of thingy which makes everything all swirly and stirs things up". That is what turbulence is, what a turbulent flow is. Turbulence isn't remarkable. In fact, it is the absence of turbulence that is remarkable. Which is why it has a special name - a laminar flow. 

A laminar flow is a flow where everything is very streamlined and smooth. Say a really slowly flowing stream of water. Turbulence on the other hand is choppy, murky. Any fountain, any river, any ocean is always turbulent. Take a pristine, placid lake and throw a tiny, irregularly shaped pebble in it, and you have created some turbulence. Yes, it would fritter away soon, but another pebble, a twig, a leaf, a fish, can spark it all off again. 

So what's turbulent equilibrium? Let's come back to this lake. The act of throwing a rock or a stick into the lake is essentially an act of adding energy to the water of the lake. So why does the lake return to being placid a minute or so later? Where did the energy go? The energy "dissipates". When you churn some liquid (or a gas) around, you dissipate energy because of friction. Much like friction between any two solids, a fluid sloshing around also experiences friction within itself. The liquid is rubbing against itself. This friction is known as viscosity. And the more sloshy, the more frothy the liquid is, the more the churn and the little shapes and patterns, the more the friction, and the more the dissipation of energy. 

In turbulence, you pump more and more and more energy into the liquid, maybe by heating it, maybe by shaking it around vigorously or maybe by some other ingenious way. The fluid shakes around, becomes more and more whorly, more sloshy, because all this energy has to find a way out. In a way, the liquid "shakes off" this excess energy by bouncing around a lot more. But this bouncing around isn't random, it has patterns. The most recognisable is perhaps the "vortex" pattern, like a whirlpool or a tornado. Even the giant red spot of Jupiter is a huge vortex of turbulent fluid. If you want to see more stunning turbulent patterns, you can check out the cloud patterns of Heard Island. And if you're interested in the a great explanation of turbulence and how important it is, I suggest this excellent video by Veritasium. 

Of course, this is all turbulent. What is this equilibrium then? It doesn't occur very often in the world, except in carefully constructed experiments. However, the concept is easy to grasp. It is a situation where whatever extra energy you add to the liquid just makes it more and more swirly and whorly so it can shake this extra energy off. Now imagine you kept supplying energy in a very constant way. And the liquid kept shaking of this energy. This is a rough situation of equilibrium. Whatever you put in, comes out by this creation of whorly thingies and the liquid friction (viscosity) associated with this. 

The mind is like this lake. The pebbles, twigs, the fish - they're all the various things that happen to us in life, the various incidents that we witness, the information that is relayed to us via the senses and our cognition. The mind gets perturbed, agitated, turbulent, due to these objects. 

Mindfulness, from what I understand, is about stillness. Where your mind is a lake that is never perturbed. No matter how many pebbles you throw, no matter how many fish ferret around in the water. No sensory input comes to you as a shock, nothing is a surprise. Perfect equanimity. Perfect equilibrium. This doesn't mean you live separate from the world of your senses. It is not a disengagement from the world, but rather an extra layer, a pause before reaction. As Viktor Frankl says "Between stimulus and response there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom.". Mindfulness is about using the power of this space. This would take supreme awareness. 

Before the lockdown, I assumed that I was pretty near, or at least not too far from this state. The lockdown exposed this faulty self-perception quite badly. Agitation! My racing mind is a lake filled with ripples and splashes and waves. What I had thought was tranquility was actually a kind of turbulent equilibrium. Life was predictable. A constant stream of incidents and information. And I had learnt to shuffle, to sway and whorl around to stay in equilibrium. The water in the lake never got too choppy, too agitated, too turbulent that I couldn't handle it. And thus it was a quasi-stable arrangement. 

Not that there is anything wrong with this. If mindfulness was so easy, there wouldn't be a gazillion videos and books and articles on how to do it. Our lives are all turbulent. Those for whom it is in turbulent equilibrium are perhaps the lucky ones. Better than turbulent unequilibrium. 

One agent I would blame is certainly social media. With it's power to lure you into endless scrolling and the stream of new information, with every new word a little pebble is flung into the lake. Even if no pebbles are thrown in, the reverberations of every thrown pebble last a few minutes before the water is placid again. 

It doesn't matter though. It is great that being alone with my thoughts with the swirling chaos all around me, stories of filled hospitals and mass burials in my country of residence, I understand this error in my self-perception. As Jordan Peterson once put it, "Competence is the acceptance of vulnerability". Onward is the only direction worth going. 

And I truly believe the mind is like a muscle. To use the language of Nassim Taleb, it is Anti-Fragile. It reacts positively to stress. You do 10 push-ups today, tomorrow you have the strength to do 11. However, this power is not endless. You suddenly try to lift a huge weight and your back will forget how to lift you up from the floor. A still mind is a strong mind. 

Jul 28, 2020

Unintended Consequences

My attention to this topic was drawn by something very interesting that I saw - a statement by a minister of Kerala. The backdrop of the statement was this - several states in India amended their labour laws to essentially grant fewer rights to workers. The argument was that strict labour laws forced companies to think twice before setting up industries in these states. The Kerala government however refused to follow this trend and said there are better ways of attracting labour than by denying them rights. And several people applauded this stance.

I am not an expert in this topic and I have also read a counter-view - that in fact the lack of industry in states has nothing to do with the labour laws. And economics is a topic I'm always afraid of saying anything due to my own ignorance. It's a topic I never understand even from a layman's perspective.

This however was an interesting point - the laws brought in to protect labour ended up causing a lack of demand for labour, allegedly. Why I found it interesting was that the state which was being hailed as the one who stood by the workers (ie. Kerala) is also the state whose young workers are willing to toil in the heat of the deserts of the Arabian peninsula where they are not guaranteed even human rights under theological monarchies, so labour rights are a far-cry away. Surely, if they had a chance to work in decent conditions back in their home state, with this high level of protection of labour rights, they would have chosen this? Or maybe we know nothing about human nature and people are just willing to jeopardise their health, futures and lives at the prospect of making a lot more money. Either way, a law on the books clearly does precious little other than allowing a government to thump its chest.

Take the example of the house I'm living in. The landlord is an extremely environmentally conscious individual. All the lights are low-electricity consuming lights, heating is switched on only at some hours during the winter. One of the measures along with these is the installation of water-saving shower heads. These shower heads partially block the flow of water and so it forces you to use less water while taking a shower. One doesn't need the full pressure flow to take a shower.

Alas, there is a problem with this. For the hot water to maintain a continuous flow, it needs the water to be running continuously. In usual circumstances, if you turn on the hot water tap, switch it off and then turn it on again, you get cold water and you've to again wait for a couple of minutes for the water to heat up. What the water-saving shower head does is that due to its blocking effect, the hot water flow keeps getting blocked and so even if the shower is kept open continuously, the water keeps getting cold. To call this a slight inconvenience is a gargantuan understatement. A nice shower of hot water is what keeps spirits of a tropical boy up in the (admittedly mild) Roman winter. There are two solutions to this - remove the shower head, which allows unobstructed flow of water, or to open another tap of hot water at a low speed to ensure the continuous flow. Either solution causes a huge amount of wastage of water and I end up using way more water than I would with a normal, high-pressure shower-head.

Let us say you want to increase the tax-revenues of a state or a country. What is the way to go about it? Of course, you increase the tax-rates. However, it could happen that when you increase the tax-rates, more people will work harder to evade the taxes and you end up pouring all your resources into chasing after tax evaders rather than just enjoying a larger inflow of tax. In fact, you might end-up hurting your tax revenue though at the surface level, you increased taxes.

An apocryphal tale from the British Raj about snakes. Due to the menace of cobras in Delhi, the British-Indian government announced a reward for those catch these snakes. This led to a bunch of enterprising Indians to start breeding cobras to claim the reward money. When the government got wind of this scheme, they discontinued the reward and so the cobra breeding reward-hunters had to release all their cobras, thus increasing the total count of cobras in Delhi.

I don't really have a point with this blog. It has been a while since I've published anything. And I found these examples to be really cute and with the potential to completely change the way we think - not just a linear jump from action to consequence, but hundreds of steps in between which can turn things any which way. At least it made me look at the world in a very different way.

Mar 27, 2020

For Whom the Bells Toll

There is a large church right outside my balcony. The dome looks grand and quite beautiful. I remember the day I moved in - I expressed the same sentiment to my flatmate. I would love to go inside the church, I said, because from my experience, every single large church I've been to in Rome, actually in all of Europe, is beautiful, very often stunningly so.

She scoffed at my suggestion. I hate that place, she said. I was surprised. She went on to explain how that particular church is run by a criminal gang and when the leader of this gang passed away, this man, with several charges of heinous crimes against him, was given a grand funeral at this church, with helicopters flying in and dropping flowers from the sky to honour his departed soul. I later found out it was an extremely controversial event that made the headlines across Italy.

I still wish to go to the church. And despite it being right next door, despite passing by it so often, I haven't gone even once even 6 months after moving here. I don't know why, something about what she said. We have a saying in Kannada, never go looking for the source/roots of a river or a sage. Both will leave you disappointed, the former because it is perhaps some tiny, unimpressive trickle of water somewhere, the latter because, like Rishi Valmiki, he was maybe a dacoit or a brute. And what is true of the sage must be true of the place of worship as well.

These days though, every time I stand on my balcony, which is pretty often, I feel a sense of longing to visit the church. Perhaps because it is next door. Unfortunately , "I wish to check out the interiors of this domed building that looks great from the outside" is not a sentence I want to learn in Italian so I can say it to the police officer, who I'm guessing will not have much patience for my lockdown breaking behaviour. The luckiest scenario would be me being slapped with a massive fine, in the thousands of Euros, while the worst case would be having to spend 3 months in prison.

All these months, every time I looked at the church and felt "I should go in sometime", going there was actually an option. I could just choose an evening or a weekend and pop in. Not anymore. Now that I do not know when I will be able to go, it just makes me think more and more about the inside of that majestic building.

The bells of the church toll at 7 pm everyday. I noticed this exact timing only around a week ago. Now it has become a rather sombre reminder. Everyday at 6 pm, the "protezione civile", the equivalent of the Home Ministry, gives a press conference about the corona virus. I don't know enough Italian to follow the press conference, but I know one little feature of the press conference. The first thing they mention is the number of people who have recovered. First, the recoveries and then all the other numbers - new infections, deaths, region-wise distribution of these numbers, etc. At the end of the press conference, around 6.40 pm, the numbers from the press conference are released on the official website of the Protezione Civile. And by 7pm, some great soul somewhere, updates the "2020 Coronavirus Pandemic in Italy" entry of Wikipedia with these latest numbers.

When the bells toll, I open my laptop  I switch from the Facebook tab to a new tab and navigate to this Wikipedia entry. I don my statistician hat and draw on my couple of years of experience in research of staring at numbers, imagining the graphs, looking for patterns, etc. to do my own little mental analysis. Was it a good day? Was it a bad day? Is the curve "flattening"? How does this compare with what happened in Wuhan? Are the Chinese lying? Surely they are. I mean, they did it before to start the whole thing. How is Lazio doing? Is the curve flattening at least in some regions? Which region dominates the numbers? What number of new infections tomorrow would indicate good news?

There are no good days. Good news? I think we'll get to hear that only 3 months from now. Or maybe 18, whoever knows.

But somehow I'm grateful for this little exercise. Time can sometimes seem to move fast, when you're doing a lot. But time can also seem to be moving fast when you're doing nothing. Minutes go slow, the days fly by. And you miss the activity. You miss the feeling of keeping track of time using how much you've done. When how tired you felt was a clue on how far past Monday it was.

When the bells toll though, there is a semblance of order. To know that across the deserted streets where the occasional ambulance passes by, in the building I imagine to be oh so beautiful, though empty, someone sits there diligently and makes sure the bell tolls at 7 pm. And I sit here diligently, a little anxiously, peering at the numbers. Until the next day, then the next. Until the lockdown is lifted and on day 1 of freedom, I finally visit the church.

Or so I plan, as I have for the last 6 months.

Dec 18, 2019

The Control Experiment

I was sipping my morning chai (at noon) and gingerly punching my own thigh. A recent football injury, where an opponent's knee had smashed into the meaty front portion of my thigh  just above the knee had left me sensitive in this region.

Immediately after the incident, I was able to carry on playing. It was after I got back home that the intensity of the pain searing through my legs became apparent. The next 2 days I could hardly walk and the region was swollen. Over time though, the pain became less intense and a visit to the doctor revealed that though the injury was of a painful nature, it was local and not serious - I just had to wait it out and it would be alright.

Now, ever since the injury, I have been eager to get back to playing football or at least jogging, but the past few days have seen a different kind of confusion - am I still injured? Sometimes the pain returns, sometimes I feel I am completely healed. This morning, while punching my own thigh, I noted the slight pain where I had received the blow. At this moment a thought struck me - I am a scientist. I have to truly assess whether I am experiencing injury pain. Think about it - have you ever punched your own thigh softly to know how much it hurts with how hard a punch? So unless there is a really sharp pain for a very soft touch, it is hard to say whether it is a normal pain or an injury-pain. So there was only one way to find out. I punched my other thigh softly in the same place with as near the same intensity as I could manage and felt a similar sting. Still I couldn't discern whether it was of lesser intensity and so I repeated the exercise until I felt ridiculous - here I was, tea in hand, punching my own thighs repeatedly with different forces in different spots.

My conclusion right now is that the lingering effects of the injury are still present and it would be unwise for me to get physically active again soon. And my other conclusion is that the human body (or at least mine) is really really sensitive to even light blows. I don't know how I withstood the blow from the original football incident without fainting.

I have always been an over-enthusiastic sportsperson with not too much talent for any sport nor a very resilient body. It has made for an unfortunate combination and I am thus the veteran of several injuries. They say you live and learn. And I have lived (thankfully) and learnt. My assorted wisdom from my most serious injury (a ligament tear in the knee that kept me limping and in pain for nearly 6 months) is that we have no clue how we do things. I started walking slightly differently to avoid the pain and forgot how I used to walk. I have no idea how my knee used to feel before injury, so now I still don't know whether it feels right. I just go with it in the changed circumstances and there is no way of ever returning truly to the state of my body pre-injury. And this happens with every injury.

When one part of one leg is injured, you will avoid putting your weight on it, so another part of your hip or other knee feels more strain. Then as you slowly heal, you adjust your walking to avoid that other pain and very quickly the "feel" of your own body becomes unrecognisable. You cannot simply say "Ok, the injury is gone, let me go back to how I was doing stuff before the injury". That is simply not possible. Through some indirect, cascading way, your body has a stored memory of each thing that has happened to it. Some incidents are remembered very strongly, others are swept away with time. That one day you had to pretend to limp because you told your class teacher than you missed the previous day due to an ankle-injury. Well now you have lost a bit of your "normal" walk. In fact, there is no normal, I think. It keeps changing but we feel it is constant. I feel I am more aware of this solely because of my numerous injuries. (Once after I sprained my shoulder playing Table Tennis, a great joke I heard at my expense was that my next injury would be from playing chess!)

"A game of two halves" is a common cliche in football, where one team plays really poorly for the first half and then plays really well after the 15 minute break at half-time. In English commentator parlance, this is known as "taking the game by the scruff of the neck". But why does this happen? There are many explanations. You see, the manager yelled at them at half-time so they came back to the field with renewed determination. But also the opposition put in a lot of effort playing so well in the first half that now they're more tired. But also there was a small but crucial tactical change by the manager. And also this one player who was having a really bad game suddenly started playing at his usual level. So what is it? A change in mentality? A change in tactics? The one crucial player? There is no control experiment again. A lot of it is to do with the mind.

One last football analogy - when a team takes the lead, they automatically seem to be more focused on defending only. No matter the coach says "Play as if the score is still 0-0". There is the instinctive desire to defend more. That's why there is a football saying that "You are most vulnerable as soon as you score". It's impossible to play as if you don't know the score when you actually know the score, no matter how hard you try. The act of scoring fundamentally changes how you think and hence who you are on the football field for the rest of the game.

When I was mid-way through my 5 year undergraduate course, my grades started falling. Well, actually they didn't "start" falling. They were alright and then suddenly they fell and also stayed down for a while. I began to think how I can rectify this situation. First step to rectify this is to find out why it is happening. Excellent question!

Well, college is harder than school. But the first few semesters were a breeze. Well, first few semesters are designed to be easy. But also I've lost a bit of interest in the subject and in studying in general. Also, have my initial good grades made me little complacent? The fear factor of exams is completely absent. But it was the same even during the initial semesters, I still studied without any fear or anxiety. What made me study then? Or am I studying the same amount, but that is not enough? Or my mind is getting less sharp? Maybe the first instance of a bad score demoralised me and I'm in a vicious cycle. Ok, let us take a step back. Grades dipped in school also. How did I get out of that cycle?

Of course, at that point of time I didn't think with so much clarity. And I didn't give this so much precise thought, just random questions in the shower or while sleeping. But now I understand something else - no solution from school would ever have helped me. I had changed so much as a person. From a structured school life staying at home to the complete freedom of hostel life. From learning really random things (like how some p-block elements react differently with cold sulphuric acid and hot sulphuric acid) to having courses in Humanities on "rational enquiry" and "scientific communication". These fundamentally altered who I am, how I think and how I do things, so I couldn't fall back to what I was doing before to solve the same problems. Priorities changed, opinions changed.

But maybe I noticed this in this phase because I was thinking about how to tackle one particular challenge after a drastic change in a short period. Maybe we are always changing. Every step alters fundamentally how we walk, every thought alters fundamentally every next thought we will ever get, and before we know it, we are constantly becoming a new person while being in the illusion that our personality is very constant. It is like the ship of thesus situation. Old solutions will not work anymore. Or maybe old attempts at solutions will suddenly become fruitful. Maybe changing the formation is counter-productive at 0-0, but at 1-0, it completely changes the game. But we can never know what works precisely. Because there is no control experiment. There never will be. No football game where only exactly one thing changed at one time. The change in formation changed your attitude along with it. And the opponents' attitude. In football and in life.

And now I will return to trying to re-create and remember how I used to walk when I have never paid attention to how I used to walk. I will return to facing new challenges everyday that I am clueless about how to solve, but 5 years from now I will write a grand blog post on how to think about it and what to learn from it and throw some more gyaan at you!

Dec 1, 2019

That is the Whole

There's something beautiful about log-log plots. Let me explain. Let us say you have 3 numbers - 0.001, 0.1 and 10. Now you draw a line of length 10 in your favourite unit with your pencil, mark one end as 0 (the left end, unless you write in Arabic or you are a psychopath) and the other end as 10. Now I ask you to make a point at these 3 values. You've already marked one end as 10, so you put one point there. But how do you make these two points 0.001 and 0.1 without them smudging each other? They're too close.

Not necessarily. If your favourite chosen unit was kilometre, then it's easy to make these marks distinct and far apart. But let me know when you find a kilometre of paper or blackboard for this excellent demonstration. The distance between 0.001 and 0.1 is 0.099. The distance between 0.1 and 10 is 9.9. The distance between 0.001 to 10 is 9.999. The 0.099 extra is nothing from the perspective of 10, but from the perspective of 0.1 it is big and for 0.001 it is massive. For the elephant, the ant and the rat are practically the same tiny size. For the rat, the elephant is a giant and the ant is tiny. For the ant, even the rat is a giant. So what's the solution?

But 0.1 and 0.001 aren't "practically the same" are they? The first is 100 times larger than the second. And 100 times larger than 0.1 is 10, which we all agree is large. So in a way, the "separation" between 0.1 and 0.001 is tiny, but it is also really large when seen in another perspective. So what's the way forward here for our original problem - to make a pencil mark at 0.001 and 0.1?

This is where the logarithm (log for short) comes in. You draw a line of length 4. You mark one end as (-3) and one end as 1. (-3) corresponds to 0.001 and 1 corresponds to 10. Because 10 raised to the minus third power is 0.001. And 10 raised to the first power is 10 itself. What you've done here is you have made "scale" more important than the absolute separation. This somehow recognises the fact 0.1 is equally separated from 0.001 and 10. It's like Gulliver peering close to the Lilliput world and finding that is all exactly identical to his world, but just at a lower scale.

Let me ask another question (rhetorically). How many numbers are there between 0 and 10? Our first instinct would be to say 9 numbers. But these are 9 whole numbers. If we draw a line of length 10, how many numbers can we mark with our pencil? These are called "Real numbers", and there are infinite real numbers between 0 and 10. Take any number from 0 to 9, put a decimal point after it and then cook up any sequence you want of how many ever digits - that's a real number between 0 and 10, from 0.78346873647823 to 9.2 to 3.000000000001. Best of luck marking them with a pencil though.

But what does this "infinite" mean? How many numbers lie between 0 and 100? Obviously, infinite again. But surely, this infinite is different in some way. A line of length 10 has infinite numbers. Now, a line of length 100 has 10 lines of length 10, each of which has infinite numbers. So this new infinite should be 10 times more than the old infinite.

There was something that I learnt in my first year maths course that amazes me - the number of numbers (real) between 0 and 100 is the same as the number of numbers between 0 and 10. Not 10 times greater, as one would expect. This is a mathematically exact fact. Of course, it is also a very basic set theory fact, but maybe I am still so stuck-up on this because I'm a physicist.

But let's go further. What about between 0 and 1000? The same. Between 0 and 1000000000000000000000000000? Exactly the same. The same as between 0 and 0.00000000000000000000001. It doesn't matter what (positive) number you stick there, the number of numbers you will find in between them are exactly the same.

Is this related to the log thingy we discussed earlier? I think so - if not directly, then at least as a way of visualising and understanding this. You saw how we first took the interval from 0.001 to 10, worked our log magic and made it in such a way 0.001 and 10 are equidistant from 0.1. So we made the intervals from 0.001 to 0.1 exactly equal to 0.1 to 10. For any such interval, we can take combinations of logs and additions and multiplications and to make them equal. This is an implicit acceptance of the fact that between any 2 numbers, there exist the same number of numbers, so we can always scale it in such a way that the distance between them can be a number of our choosing. We did exactly this by taking a log and making the distance between 0.001 and 0.1 the same as the distance between 0.1 and 10.

Ok, so this is for finite numbers. What about if we call in the big guy, the guy who changes the rules when he walks in? Infinity. How many numbers are there between 0 and infinity? The answer is again the same. The same as the number of numbers between 0 and 1. And 0 and 0.00001. And between 0 and 1000000.

What is infinity? Infinity is that number which trumps all other numbers. You give me any number and ask me which number is greater, I can say infinity and I would be right. In fact, it was basically invented to do this job. It exists only in our heads.

Now let us go back to the numbers between 0 and 1. ALL the numbers.Can you give me a number greater than all these numbers? Yes, of course. 1.1 is greater than all numbers that are between 0 and 1. So is 1.000001. So is 100000. and so is infinity. In this regard, for the all the numbers between 0 and 1, the number 1.1 or 2 play the same role that infinity plays for the entire number line. Pick any number and infinity is greater. Pick any number between 0 and 1 and 1.1 is greater. We can extend this to say 100000000+1 is like the infinity for the numbers between 0 and 100000000. And maybe, we can extend this is ALL numbers and infinity itself. Usually, just invoking infinity changes the rules, but here it doesn't. And with my slight mathematical training, I am confident that if I sat down and read about it for a few days I could get it, but this kind of abstraction has never been my strong suit, so here I will believe the mathematicians blindly. (nothing new for a physicist to do)

Each little section of the real line, no matter what the length, in a way, contains the whole real number line. Every chunk has this property, as does, quite obviously, the whole real line, which stretches to infinity. So the next time someone at a party asks you to draw a line all the way to infinity, just draw a straight line and label the 2 ends with your favourite real numbers and tell them it's practically the same thing. You'll surely be invited to the next one.

My grandfather has studied Vedanta and I love to pick his brain whenever I get the chance. I remember him quoting a mantra during a discussion about something -

पूर्णमदः पूर्णमिदम्
पूर्णात् पूर्णमुदच्यते |
पूर्णस्य पूर्णमादाय
​पूर्णमेवावशिष्यते ||

This is the "Shanti Mantra" of the Ishavasya Upanishad. Poornam could be translated as the whole, or the complete, or everything. The gist of the translation my grandfather gave me is this (with help from the first couple of results when you google this) - 

That is the whole. This is the whole. From the whole comes the whole. Taking the whole from the whole, what remains is still whole. 

This is a view on the cosmos (or maybe Brahman, I'm not sure, I'm not even close to being an expert). And I found it really cool that the imagination of the cosmos here is very similar to the number line, which when you consider the infinity at the end of it, is also an abstraction, a figment of our collective imagination. 

This little section of the real number line is the whole real number line. That also is the whole real number line. If you take a section out of it (which is whole), the remaining section is still the whole real number line. It's a beautiful idea, that there is the entire cosmos in every small bit of matter. It reminds me of a (probably fake) conversation where someone asked Michelangelo how he made such a beautiful sculpture of David out of a shapeless chunk of rock and Michelangelo said that the David has always been in the rock, his job was merely to scrape out the rock that was covering it. Every rock is a potential David, every stone, made of stardust, contains within it as many secrets as the entire cosmos itself. And by knowing this stone perfectly, you can understand the entire cosmos. By knowing your own self completely, you can know the higher self.

But there's something deeper in this. Every bit of the real number line can be identified with the whole real number line, but it isn't identical. They have some properties which make them identical in some scale. But each number, or each collection of numbers has its own identity and properties. It is why Kanaka Dasa could compose thousands of Krithis in dedicated specifically to Kaginele Adikeshava or Basavanna could write his vachanas addressing Kudala Sangama Deva. These are really local deities, perhaps the temples and the forms of the deities here not known to people outside their district, not far outside Karnataka for sure. Yet, these learned men spoke of these deities as the masters of the universe. Not because they are one and the same as the entire cosmos, but simple because they are a part of it. It does not diminish the deity in the temple two streets away, who is also local, but also the master of the universe.

Aug 28, 2019

ಮನಸು ಮನಸುಗಳ ಮಾತು

ಒಮೊಮ್ಮೆ  ನನಗೆ  ಅನಿಸುತ್ತದೆ, ನನ್ನೊಳಗೆ ಎರಡೆರಡು ಜೀವ ಇದೆ . ಒಂದು ನಾನು. ನನ್ನ ದೇಹ, ನನ್ನ ಮನಸ್ಸು ಮತ್ತು ನನ್ನ ಮನಃಸಾಕ್ಷಿ . ಇನ್ನೊಂದು ಕೇವಲ ಧ್ವನಿಯಾಗಿ ಉಳಿದಿರುವ ಒಂದು ಶುದ್ಧ ತಾರ್ಕಿಕ ಮನುಷ್ಯ. ಈ ಮನುಷ್ಯನ ಪ್ರಭಾವ ನನ್ನಮೇಲೆ ಕಡಿಮೆ ಏನು ಅಲ್ಲ.ಹಾಗಿದ್ದರೂ ಹೆಚ್ಚಾಗಿ ಇವನ ಮಾತು ನಾನು ಕೇಳುವುದಿಲ್ಲ. ಇವನದು ಬರೀ  ಲೆಕ್ಕಾಚಾರ - ಭಯ, ಭೀತಿ, ನಗುವು ಅಳುವು ಯಾವದೂ ಇಲ್ಲ. ಕೆಲವೊಮ್ಮೆ ನನ್ನೊಟ್ಟಿಗೆ ಬೇಡದೇ ಇರೊ ಅಧಿಕಪ್ರಸಂಗ ಕೂಡ ಮಾಡುತ್ತಾನೆ.  ಆದರೆ ಒಟ್ಟು ಎಲ್ಲ ಸೇರಿಸಿ ನೋಡಿದರೆ ಒಳ್ಳೆ ಉಪದೇಶವನ್ನೇ ಮಾಡುತ್ತಾನೆ ಮತ್ತು ಇನ್ನೂ ಮುಖ್ಯವಾಗಿ ಒಳ್ಳೆ ಉದ್ದೇಶ ಇಟ್ಟುಕೊಂಡು ಅವನಿಗೆ ತಿಳಿದಿರುವ ವಿಷಯಗಳನ್ನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತಾನೆ. ನನ್ನ ಮಿತ್ರ ಅಂತಾನೇ ಹೇಳಬಹುದು. 

ಇನ್ನ ಮುಂದೆ ಇವನನ್ನು ‘ತಾ’ ಎಂದು ಮತ್ತೆ ನನನ್ನು ‘ನ’ ಎಂದು ಕರೆಯಲಾಗುತ್ತದೆ - 

ತಾ : ಏನಪ್ಪ ಈ ನಡುವೆ ದೇವರು ದಿಂಡ್ರು  ಅಂತೆಲ್ಲ ನಿಂದು ಜಾಸ್ತಿ ಆಗುತ್ತಾ  ಇದೆ. ನಿನ್ನೆ ಜನಮಾಷ್ಟಮಿ ಪೂಜೆಗೂ ಕೂಡ  ಹೋದೆ. ಒಬ್ಬ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನಿಯಾಗಿ ಇದೆಲ್ಲ ಮಾಡುವುದು ಸರೀ ನಾ? 

ನ : ಏನು ಮಾಡಿದೆ ಈಗ ನಾನು? ದೇವರು ಅಂತಲ್ಲ, ಸುಮ್ಮನೆ ಹಾಗೆ ಒಂದು ಹೊಸ ದೃಷ್ಟಿಕೋನದಿಂದ ಎಲ್ಲ ವಿಷಯಗಳನ್ನ ನೋಡಲು ಸ್ವಲ್ಪ ನಮ್ಮ ಧರ್ಮದ ತತ್ವಗಳ ಬಗ್ಗೆ ಕೇಳುತ್ತಿದ್ದೇನೆ.

ತಾ : ಆಹಾ ಸ್ವಲ್ಪವೇನೋ? ಪ್ರತಿರಾತ್ರಿ ಭಗವದ್ಗೀತೆ ಪ್ರವಚನಾ ನೇ ಕಿವಿಗೆ ಹಾಕೊಂಡು ನಿದ್ರೆ ಮಾಡುವುದು ಸ್ವಲ್ಪ ನಾ? 

ನ : ದಿನಾಗಲೂ ಒಂದು ೫-೧೦ ನಿಮಿಷ  ಅಷ್ಟೇ. ಅದರಲ್ಲಿ ಹೇಗೆ ಬಾಳುವುದು ಅಂತ ಉಪದೇಶ ಮಾಡುತ್ತಾರೆ. ಅದಕ್ಕೂ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನಕ್ಕೂ  ಏನು ಸಂಬಂಧ? 

ತಾ : ಲೇ! ಅದು, ದೇವರು ಹೀಗೆ, ಸೃಷ್ಟಿ ಹಾಗಾಯಿತು, ಲೋಕದ ಗುಣ ಹೀಗೆ ಅಂತೆಲ್ಲ ಬಾಯಿಗೆ ಬಂದಂತೆ ಹೇಳುವುದಿಲ್ಲವೇ? 

ನ : ಅದು ಅಲ್ಲ! ಅವರು

ತಾ : ಯಾರು?

ನ : ವೇದ ವ್ಯಾಸರು 

ತಾ : ಆಯಿತಪ್ಪ .ರಾಜಕೀಯ ಸೇರು ನೀನು.ಹೀಗೆ ವಿಷಯ ಬದಲಾಯಿಸಿ ಬದಲಾಯಿಸಿ ಉದ್ದಾರ ಆಗುತ್ತೀಯ. ಅದೋ ಅವರೋ. ನಾನು ಕೇಳಿದ್ದೇನು? 

ನ : ಅಲ್ಲ ಹೇಳಿದ್ದು ಅಷ್ಟೇ. ಭಗವದ್ಗೀತೆ ಒಂದು ವಸ್ತು ಮಾತ್ರವಲ್ಲ.ಅದು ಯಾರೋ ಬರೆದಿದ್ದು.

ತಾ : ಏನೀಗ? ಸರಿ, ಅವನು ಇರೋ ಬರೋ ಮಾತಾಡುತ್ತಾನೆ. ವೇದ ವ್ಯಾಸಾ ನೇ 

ನ : ನೋಡಪ್ಪ, ನಿನ್ನ ತರ್ಕ ಏನಾಗಿದ್ದರು ಒಂದು ಗುರಿ ಇದ್ದರೆ ಮಾತ್ರ ಕೆಲಸಕ್ಕೆ ಬರುವುದು. ಹೀಗೆ ಸುಮ್ಮನೆ ಗುರಿ ಇಲ್ಲದ ತರ್ಕಕ್ಕೆ  ಏನು ಅರ್ಥ ಇಲ್ಲ. 

ತಾ : ಅಂದ್ರೆ?

ನ : ನಮಗೆ ಏನೋ ಒಂದು ಬೇಕು ಅಂದರೆ  ತಾರ್ಕಿಕವಾಗಿ ಅದು ಹೇಗೆ ಪಡೆಯಬಹುದು ಎನ್ನುವದರ ಬಗ್ಗೆ ಚಿಂತನೆ ಮಾಡಬಹುದು. ಅಥವಾ ನಾವು ಏನನ್ನೋ ಕಂಡಿದ್ದೇವೆ ಅಂದ್ರೆ ಅದನ್ನು ವಿವರಿಸಲು ನಮಗೆ ತರ್ಕ ಬೇಕು.ಎಲ್ಲಿಯ ವರೆಗೆ ನಮಗೆ ತಿಳುವಳಿಕೆ ಇದೆಯೋ ಅಲ್ಲಿಂದ ತರ್ಕದಿಂದ ಮುಂದೆವರೆದು ನಾವು ಕಂಡಿದ್ದನ್ನು ಸ್ಪಷ್ಟವಾಗಿ ವಿವರಿಸಬಹುದು 

ತಾ : ಒಪ್ಪಿಕೊಂಡೆ.ಅದೇ ನಾನು ಯಾವಾಗಲೂ ಹೇಳುವುದು.ನೀನು ಕೇಳುವುದಿಲ್ಲ 

ನ : ನಾನು ಕೇಳುತ್ತೇನೆ.ಆದರೆ ನೀನು ಅರ್ಥ ಮಾಡಿಕೊಳ್ಳುವುದಿಲ್ಲ. ನನ್ನ ಗುರಿ ಏನು? 

ತಾ : ಒಬ್ಬ ದೊಡ್ಡ ಮತ್ತು ಪ್ರಸಿದ್ಧ ವಿಜ್ಞಾನಿ ಆಗುವುದೇ? ಅಥವಾ ಒಂದು ಸೊಗಸಾದ ಹುಡುಗಿಯನ್ನು ಕಟ್ಟಿಕೊಳ್ಳುವುದೇ? 

ನ : ನೋಡು ಇದೇ  ನಿನ್ನ ಸಮಸ್ಯೆ .ಯಾವದೋ ಒಂದೋ ಎರಡೋ ವಿಷಯ ಹಿಡಿದುಕೊಂಡು ಇರುತ್ತೀಯ. ಸಾಮಾನ್ಯವಾಗಿ ಏನು ಬೇಕು ಒಬ್ಬ ಮನುಷ್ಯನಿಗೆ? 

ತಾ : ನಾನು ಒಂದು ಯಂತ್ರ.ಮನುಷ್ಯರ ಭಾವನೆಗಳ ಬಗ್ಗೆ ನನಗೇನು ಗೊತ್ತಿಲ್ಲ 

ನ : ಒಹೋ!! ನಿನ್ನಿಂದ “ಗೊತ್ತಿಲ್ಲ” ಎನ್ನುವ ಮಾತು ಕೇಳಿದ್ದೇ ನನ್ನ ಪುಣ್ಯ! 

ತಾ : ಲೇ ತಲೆಹರಟೆ ಮಾಡ್ಬೇಡ.

ನ : ನೋಡಪ್ಪ ನನ್ನ ಗುರಿ ಏನಿದ್ದರೂ ಸುಖವಾಗಿ ಇರುವುದು. ನನ್ನ ಗುರಿ ಮನಶ್ಶಾಂತಿ

ತಾ : ಈ ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆಗಳಿಂದ ಮನಶ್ಶಾಂತಿ ಸಿಗುವುದೇ ? 

ನ : ಎಲ್ಲರಿಗು ಈ ಭೂಮಿಯಮೇಲೆ ಪ್ರತ್ಯಕ್ಷವಾಗಿ ಕಾಣುವಂತ ವಸ್ತುಗಳಿಂದ ಅರ್ಥ ಮತ್ತು ಪ್ರೇರಣೆ ಸಿಗುವುದಿಲ್ಲ.ಒಂದು ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆ ಇರಲೇಬೇಕು. ನಮ್ಮ ಸಮಾಜ ನಡೆಯುವುದೇ ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆಗಳಿಂದ 

ತಾ : ಏನು ಹಾಗೆಂದರೆ ? ನೀನು ಈಗ ಏನೇನೋ ಮಾತಾಡುತ್ತಿದ್ದೀ ಯ! 

ನ : ಒಂದು ಕತೆ  ನಿಜ ಕತೆ ಇರಲಿ ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆ ಇರಲಿ .ಈ ಥರ ಒಬ್ಬ ದೇವರಿದ್ದಾನೆ ಅಂತ ನಾನು ಕಣ್ಣು ಮುಚ್ಚಿಕೊಂಡು ನಂಬಿದರೆ ಅದರಿಂದ ನನಗೆ ಒಂತರ ನೆಮ್ಮದಿ ಸಿಗುತ್ತದೆ. ದಿನವೆಲ್ಲ ಆಫೀಸಿನಲ್ಲಿ ದುಡಿದು ದಣಿದು ಮನೆಗೆ ಬಂದಮೇಲೆ ಆ ಯಾವ್ದೋ ಒಂದು ಕತೆ ಕೇಳಿದರೆ ತುಂಬ ಶಾಂತಿ ಉಂಟುಮಾಡುತ್ತದೆ .ಹಾಗೆ ಒಬ್ಬ ದೇವರಿದ್ದಾನೆ ಮತ್ತು ಅವನು ಎಲ್ಲವನ್ನು ಹಾಳಾಗದಂತೆ ನೋಡಿಕೊಳ್ಳುತ್ತಾನೆ ಅಂತ ನಂಬಿದರೆ ಕೂಡ ನೆಮ್ಮದಿ ಉಂಟು ಮಾಡುತ್ತದೆ . “Hope is hope, whether real or fake” 

ತಾ : ನನಗೆ ಇದು ಒಪ್ಪಿಕೊಳ್ಳುವುದು ಕಷ್ಟ .ಆದರೆ ಇರಲಿ . ನನ್ನ ಚಿಂತೆ ಏನೆಂದರೆ ಈ ದೇವರ ಕತೆ ಇಲ್ಲಿಗೆ ನಿಲ್ಲುವುದಿಲ್ಲ .ನಿನ್ನ ದೇವರಿಗಿಂತ ನನ್ನ ದೇವರು ಉನ್ನತ ಮತ್ತು ಶ್ರೇಷ್ಠ ಅಂತ ಜಂಜಾಟ ಶುರು ಆಗುತ್ತದೆ. ಆಮೇಲೆ ನನ್ನ ದೇವರು ನಿಜ ನಿನ್ನ ದೇವರು ಸುಳ್ಳು . ನಮ್ಮ ಧರ್ಮ ಉದ್ಧಾರಕ್ಕೆ ದಾರಿ ನಿನ್ನ ಧರ್ಮ ವಿನಾಶ, ದುಷ್ಟತನಕ್ಕೆ ದಾರಿ. ಈ ಒಂದೋ ಎರಡೋ ಮಕ್ಕಳ ಕತೆಗಳನ್ನು ಮೀರಿ ಇದೇ ಒಂದು ದೊಡ್ಡ ವಿಷಯವಾಗುತ್ತದೆ. ಯುದ್ಧಕ್ಕೆ ನರಮೇಧಕ್ಕೆ ಇತಿಹಾಸದಲ್ಲಿ ಇದೇ ಅತಿ ದೊಡ್ಡ ಕಾರಣವಾಗಿತ್ತು .

ನ : ಇರಬಹುದು . ನನ್ನ ಪ್ರಕಾರ ಯುದ್ಧ ಮತ್ತು ಜಗಳಗಳು ನಮ್ಮ ಮಾನವ ಸಮಾಜದ ಸ್ವಭಾವ ಹೊರೆತು ಅದು ಧರ್ಮದ ಸ್ವಭಾವವಲ್ಲ . ನಾವು ನಂಬಿರುವುದು ಎಲ್ಲ ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆಗಳನ್ನೇ .ನಾನು ಹೇಳಿದ್ದೆನಲ್ಲ, ನಮ್ಮ ಸಮಾಜ ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆ ಗಳಿಂದಲೇ ನಡೆಯುವುದು.ಈ ಭಾರತ ದೇಶ ಅಂತ ನಿಜವಾಗಿ ಇದೆಯೇ? .ಇದು ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆ ಅಲ್ಲವೇ ? ನಾವು ಎಲ್ಲ ಕನ್ನಡಿಗರು  ಒಂದೇ ಮೂಲದಿಂದ   ಎನ್ನುವುದೂ ಕೂಡ ಒಂದು ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆ. ಎಷ್ಟು ಕನ್ನಡಿಗ ರಾಜಗಳ ನಡುವೆ ಪರಸ್ಪರ ಯುದ್ಧ ನಡೆದಿದೆಯೋ ಹಿಂದೆ . ಈ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕ ರಾಜ್ಯವೂ ಒಂದು ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆನೇ. ಮಾನವ ಹಕ್ಕುಗಳು ಮತ್ತು ನಮ್ಮ ಸಂವಿಧಾನ ಕೂಡ. 

ನಮ್ಮ ಸಮಾಜದಲ್ಲಿ ಸಂಪೂರ್ಣ ಸಮಾನತೆ ಮೂಡಿ ಬಂದರೆ ಯಾರೂ ಕಳ್ಳತನ ಮಾಡುವುದಿಲ್ಲ ಮತ್ತು ಜನರ ಎಲ್ಲ ಸ್ವಾರ್ಥಗಳೂ ಆವಿಯಾಗುತ್ತದೆ ಅಂತ ಕೊಮ್ಯೂನಿಸ್ಟ್ ಅವರು ಹೇಳುತ್ತಾರೆ . ಅದು ಒಂದು ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆ ಅಂತ ಹೇಳಕ್ಕಾಗಲ್ಲ, ಆದರೆ ಒಂದು ಭ್ರಮೆ ಅಂತ ನೇ ಹೇಳಬೇಕು . ಇಂತಹ ಪರಿಸ್ಥಿತಿಯಲ್ಲಿ ಸಾವಿರಾರು ವರುಷಗಳ ಹಿಂದೆ ಒಬ್ಬ ಯುವರಾಜ ತೇಲಾಡುವ ಬಂಡೆಗಳ ಸೇತುವೆ ಕಟ್ಟಿ ಕಡಲು ದಾಟಿದ ಮತ್ತು ಇಂದು ಅವನನ್ನು ಪೂಜಿಸಿದರೆ ಅವನು ಅನುಗ್ರಹಿಸುತ್ತಾನೆ  ಎನ್ನುವದು ಕೂಡ ಅಷ್ಟೇ ತಪ್ಪು ಅಥವಾ ಸರಿ . ಏನೋ ಒಂದು ಅನುಸರಿಸುವುದಕ್ಕೆ ಅದರ ಹಿಂದೆ ಇರೋ ನಂಬಿಕೆಗೆ ಸಾಕ್ಷಿ ಇರಲೇಬೇಕು ಎನ್ನುತ್ತೀಯಾ? ನನ್ನ ವೈಯಕ್ತಿಕ ನಂಬಿಕೆಗಳು  ಕೂಡ  ಏಕೆ ತಾರ್ಕಿಕವಾಗಿ  ಇರಬೇಕು? ಅವಿಂದ  ನನಗೆ  ನೆಮ್ಮದಿ  ಬರಬೇಕು ಅಷ್ಟೇ 

ತಾ : ಅಯ್ಯೋ ರಾಮ ನೀನು ಈ ಥರ ಮಾತಾಡುವುದು ಶುರು ಹಚ್ಚಿಕೊಂಡಿದ್ದೀಯೇನೋ? ಆದರೆ  ಈ ನಿನ್ನ ವೈಯಕ್ತಿಕ ನಂಬಿಕೆ  ಎಲ್ಲರು ನಂಬಿ  ಈ  ನಂಬಿರೋ ಗುಂಪು  ಸಮಾಜದಲ್ಲಿ  ಈ ನಂಬಿಕೆ ಗೋಸ್ಕರ  ಗಾಲಾಟೆ ಮತ್ತು  ಹಿಂಸೆ ಮಾಡಿದರೆ ಯಾರು  ಜವಾಬ್ದಾರರು ? 

ನ : ನಾವು ನಂಬಿಕೆಗಳ ಅಳತೆ ಮಾಡುವುದು ಹೇಗೆ? ಒಬ್ಬ ಮನುಷ್ಯ ಏನನ್ನೋ ನಂಬುತ್ತಾನೆ ಅಂತ ಹೇಳಿದರೆ ಆ ಮಾತನ್ನು ಖಚಿತಪಡಿಸಲು ಸಾಧ್ಯ ನ? ಮತ್ತೆ ಒಬ್ಬ ತಾರ್ಕಿಕನಾಗಿ ನೀನು ಯಾಕೆ ನಂಬಿಕೆಗಳ ಹಿಂದೆ ಓಡುತ್ತಿದ್ದೀ? ಅದಕ್ಕೆ ಸಾಕ್ಷಿ ಅಂತ ಏನೂ ಇಲ್ಲ .ಇದು ನನ್ನ ನಂಬಿಕೆ ಅದು ನಿನ್ನ ನಂಬಿಕೆ ಅಂತ ಬಾಯಿಗೆ ಬಂದಂತೆ ನಾವು ಹೇಳಬಹುದು . ನಿನ್ನ ತರ್ಕ ಏನಿದ್ದರೂ ಕ್ರಿಯೆಗಳ ಜೊತೆ ಇರಬೇಕು, ನಂಬಿಕೆಗಳ ಜೊತೆ ಅಲ್ಲ .ಅವನು ಏನು ನಂಬಿದ ಅಂತ ನೋಡಬೇಡ .ಅವನು ಏನು ಮಾಡಿದ ಅಂತ ನೋಡು . ಅದನ್ನ ನಾವು ಅಳತೆ ಮಾಡಬಹುದು ಹಾಗೇ ತಾರ್ಕಿಕ ಪರಿಶೀಲನೆ ಮಾಡಬಹುದು. ನಂಬಿಕೆಗೆ ಅಲ್ಲ.

ತಾ : ಹೌದು. ಆದರೆ ಇದರ ಅವಶ್ಯಕತೆ ಏನು? ಯಾವುದೇ ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆ ಇಲ್ಲದೆ ಕೂಡ ಬಾಳಬಹುದು. ದೇಶವೂ ಬೇಡ ನಾಡೂ ಬೇಡ ದೇವರೂ ಬೇಡ ಸಮಾನ ಸಮಾಜವೂ ಬೇಡ.ನಿನಗೆ ನೀನೇ ಸುಖ ತರಬಹುದು. ಅವಾಗ ಯಾವ ವಸ್ತುಗಳಿಂದ ಸುಖ ಬರುತ್ತದೆಯೋ ಅವನ್ನು ಪಡೆಯಲು ಹೋರಾಡು.ಅದು ಹೇಗೆ ಪಡೆಯುವುದು ನಾನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತೇನೆ ನನಗೆ ತಿಳಿದಿರುವ ಮಟ್ಟದ ವರೆಗು. 

ನ : ಅದು ಮಾನವ ಸ್ವಭಾವ . ನಮ್ಮ ಡಿ. ಎನ್. ಎ. ಯ ಶಾಪ. ನಮಗೆ ಬೇರೆ ಅವರ ಜೊತೆ ಇರುವ ಸಂಗತಿಗಳಿಂದಲೇ ಸಂತೋಷ ಸಿಗುವುದು. ಇದು ನಿನಗೂ ಗೊತ್ತು. ಮತ್ತು ಈ ಕಟ್ಟು ಕತೆಗಳಿಂದ ಇವರು ನಮ್ಮವರು ಅವರು ನಮ್ಮವರಲ್ಲ ಅಂತ ಹೇಳಲು ಸಾಧ್ಯ. “Tribal instinct” ಅಂತ ಹೇಳುತ್ತಾರಲ್ಲ - ಅದು.

ತಾ : ಆದರೆ ನಾನು ಕಂಡಂತೆ ಬಹಳಷ್ಟು ಜನರು ಅವರಾಗಿಯೇ ಖುಷಿಯಾಗಿ ಇದ್ದಾರೆ . ಒಂಟಿತನದಲ್ಲಿ ತುಂಬಾ ಜನಕ್ಕೆ ಸುಖವಿದೆ

ನ : ಅದು ನಿಜ . ಆದರೆ ಈ ಥರ ಎಷ್ಟು ಜನರು ಇದ್ದಾರೆ ? ಅವರು ಏನೋ ಪುಣ್ಯ ಮಾಡಿದ್ದಾರೆ ಅವರಾಗಿಯೇ ಸುಖವಾಗಿ ಇದ್ದಾರೆ ಎಂದರೆ . ನಮ್ಮೆಲ್ಲರಿಗೂ ಆ ಥರ ಗಟ್ಟಿ ಮನಸ್ಸು ಇಲ್ಲ . ಅಷ್ಟು ಸ್ಥಿರ ಮನಸ್ಸೂ ಇಲ್ಲ. ನಮ್ಮೆಲ್ಲರ ಬಾಳಿನಲ್ಲಿ ಒಂದಲ್ಲಾ ಒಂದು ಗೊಂದಲ ಇದ್ದೇ ಇರುತ್ತದೆ . ಅಂತ ಸಂದರ್ಭದಲ್ಲಿ ನಾವಾಗ್ನಾವೇ ಸುಖವಾಗಿರಲು ಸಾಧ್ಯವೇ? ಅವಾಗ ನಮ್ಮ ಮನಸು ಇಂತ ಒಂದು ತಂಡ ಹುಡುಕುತ್ತದೆ , ಇವರು ನಮ್ಮವರು ಅಂತ ಹೇಳುವುದಕ್ಕೆ .
ಬೇರೆ ಅವರಿಂದ ಅಥವಾ ಯಾವ್ದೋ ಒಂದು ತತ್ವ ಅಥವಾ ಭಾವನೆ ಇಂದ ಬಾಳಿಗೆ ಒಂದು ಅರ್ಥ ಎಂಬುದನ್ನು ಹುಡುಕುವುದರಲ್ಲಿ ಮನಸು ಅದಾಗೆ ತೊಡಕುತ್ತದೆ . ದಿನಾ ಬೆಳಿಗ್ಗೆ ಎದ್ದು ಲವಲವಿಕೆ ಇಂದ ಇರುವುದಕ್ಕೆ ಒಂದು ಪ್ರೇರಣೆ ಅಥವಾ ಒಂದು ಗುರಿ ಅಂತ ಇರಲೇಬೇಕು. ಇದು ಹೊರಗಿನಿಂದಲೇ ಬರುವುದು ಸಾಮಾನ್ಯವಾಗಿ . ಅದೇ ಹುಡುಕಾಟ  ವಿಸ್ತಾರವಾಗಿ ಈ ಥರ ನಂಬಿಕೆಗಳನ್ನು ಮೂಡಿಸುತ್ತದೆ 
ನಾವು  ನಮ್ಮನಾವೆ ಅತಿ ತಾರ್ಕಿಕರು ಅಂತ ತಿಳಿದರು ನಾವು ಆಳವಾಗಿ ಯೋಚಿಸಿದರೆ ನಾವು ಅಷ್ಟು ಏನು ತಾರ್ಕಿಕರು ಅಲ್ಲ ಅಂತ ಗೊತ್ತಾಗುತ್ತದೆ. ಇರುವುದಕ್ಕೆ ಸಾಧ್ಯವೂ ಇಲ್ಲ. “ತರ್ಕ ಉನ್ನತ, ಆದರೆ ಮಾನವ ಮನಸಿನ ತಾರ್ಕಿಕ ಬಲ ಮತ್ತು ಸಾಮರ್ಥ್ಯ ಸೀಮಿತ” ಅಂತ ಒಂದು ಕಡೆ ತುಂಬಾ ಚೆನ್ನಾಗಿರುವ ಸಾಲು ಓದಿದ್ದೆ ನಾನು 

ತ : ಹ್ಮ್! ನಿನ್ನ ಮಾತಲ್ಲಿ ಎಲ್ಲೋ ಒಂದು ತಪ್ಪಿದೆ ಆದರೆ ಏನು ಅಂತ ಕೂಡಲೇ ಹೇಳುವುದಕ್ಕೆ ಬರುತ್ತಿಲ್ಲ. ನಾನು ಸ್ವಲ್ಪ ಯೋಚಿಸಿ ನನ್ನ ಉತ್ತರ ನೀಡುತ್ತೀನಿ

ನ : ಆಗಲಿ! ಇಲ್ಲೇ ಇರುತ್ತೀನಿ. ನನಗೂ ತಾರ್ಕಿಕವಾಗಿಯೇ ಜೀವನ ನಡೆಯಿಸಬೇಕು ಅಂತ ಇಷ್ಟ. ಆದರೆ ಸಂಪೂರ್ಣವಾಗಿ ಆಗಲಿಲ್ಲ ಅಂದರೆ ಆದಷ್ಟು ತಾರ್ಕಿಕವಾಗಿ ನಡೆಯಿಸುವುದರಲ್ಲಿ ಏನು ಅರ್ಥ ಇಲ್ಲ ಅನಿಸುತ್ತದೆ. ಜಗತ್ತಿನಲ್ಲಿ ಪ್ರತಿ ಒಂದು ವಿಷಯದ ಬಗ್ಗೆ  ಸಂಪೂರ್ಣ ಮಾಹಿತಿ ಇಲ್ಲದೆ ಹೋದರೆ  ಇದಕ್ಕೆ ಅರ್ಥ ಇಲ್ಲ. ಅರೆ ತಾರ್ಕಿಕ (Half-logical) ಅಂತ ಏನು ಇಲ್ಲ. ಹೀಗಿದ್ದಾಗ ಎಲ್ಲಿ ತರ್ಕದಿಂದ ನಮ್ಮ ಕೆಲಸ ಆಗಬೇಕೋ ಅಲ್ಲಿ ಉಪಯೋಗಿಸೋಣ. ನಮ್ಮ ಲ್ಯಾಬ್ ಮತ್ತು ಸಂಶೋಧನೆಗಳಲ್ಲಿ. ಮಿಕ್ಕಿದ್ದು ದೇವರ ಹೆಸರು ಹೇಳಿಕೊಂಡೋ ಅಥವಾ ನಾಣ್ಯ ಮೇಲೆಸೆದು ಯಾವ ಕಡೆ ಬೀಳುತ್ತೋ ಅದರ ಪ್ರಕಾರ ಜೀವನ ನಡೆಯೀಸೋಣ 

ತ : ಈ ಮಾತುಕತೆ ಇಲ್ಲಿಗೆ ಇನ್ನು ಮುಗಿದಿಲ್ಲ! ಒಂದು ದಿನ ನೀನು ನನ್ನ ಎಲ್ಲ ಮಾತು ಕೇಳುತ್ತೀಯ! 

ನ : ನೋಡೋಣ ಸ್ವಾಮಿ 

Aug 25, 2019

A Sense of History - Part 1*

Over the past one or two years, one topic has captured my imagination - so much so that almost all articles and books I'm reading recently are about this. History. More specifically Indian history.

I wish I could give a nice story about how it all started off - one day I was reading something when something intrigued me. From there I started reading so many Wikipedia articles and my interest was piqued further and it has become a burning passion ever since. No, that is not how it happened. In fact, I am not sure when it happened. The fascination with history just slowly crept into my mind and has firmly set up shop there. However, if I ever write my autobiography, I would certainly write some fake story about sitting in a quiet library somewhere and stumbling upon some book about history that changed my life.

I think this is exactly what history is - it isn't a collection of facts. It is a story woven around facts, not always true. "Indian history" itself is something fake for a simple reason - there was no India, hence there can be no Indian history. So when we say Chanakya was an Indian, we're telling ourselves a story of who we are. And this story is decided by a huge number of factors - facts of history, territory, religion, culture and current politics. Was Mohammad of Ghori Indian? Certainly not. Was he Pakistani? Well, they name their missiles after him and they claim to be inheritors of his legacy, so perhaps. Just as we claim to be inheritors of Chandragupta Maurya. Here it isn't about land. But what about Akbar? Both countries say he was theirs and theirs alone.  Controversial, to say the least. Depends on who has most Lok Sabha seats, I guess! :D

The "story" isn't an impediment even though we want to be rational beings and only live with facts. Take Newton's Law of Gravitation for example. If we were to live with the facts only, we would just have massive charts of planetary movements. Instead, we can replace this with a one-line story. "The masses attract each other with a force proportional to the product of their masses and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them." Is this a true story? To a degree only. That's where Einstein comes in.

History however is subjective, planetary movements are objective and can be measured. They can be simulated - can you run a simulation of an Empire? You can only fantasise about "what if?" in history. What if Vijayanagara wasn't sacked and the army of the Karnataka empire had won at Talikota in 1565? This question is very very different from "What if the sun was 1.5 times its mass?"

I'm rambling here though. Moving to Rome in Italy obviously only increased my fascination with history. The Piazza Venezia in Rome is perhaps the most stunning place I've ever been to. Grandeur all around, the Colloseum at the end of the road just out of sight. And a few thoughts struck me. This Colloseum was built in the B.C. era. There was a bustling marketplace and the home of Roman emperors nearby. These buildings were plundered, sacked, rebuilt, destroyed by earthquakes, built again. Still the Colloseum stands proud. But so do so many other grand buildings nearby. It isn't just a story of continuous habitation. It is about people in power somehow being drawn to this small radius and trying to leave their own mark on history here. Trying to build something large, maybe something that will last as long as the Colloseum. Why is that?

I think people understand they're part of something bigger, something wider. Today Tamil Nadu and Karnataka fight over water and other issues, but we Kannadigas have slang words to describe Tamilians in not so generous terms. A recent visit to some temple towns in Karnataka shed some light on this - the Cholas/Pallavas and Chalukyas were also enemies. Armies broke each other's palaces and temples. Kannada inscriptions were ordered in the Pallava capital as a mark of humiliation and defeat and vice-versa. Even the situation in Kashmir I think can be viewed with this lens - it is at an intersection of the Islamic/Arab/Persian/Turkic, the "Indian" and the "Chinese" spheres of influence historically**. These spheres have waxed and waned with time as well. We might be cocooned into nation-states, but even hard borders don't prevent the flow of history. An open border like the one between Karnataka and Tamil Nadu doesn't simply erase it overnight either. It is perhaps embedded deep within human nature. Tribalism. (I met a lady who told me that during the heights of the Kaveri dispute, the name of the incumbent Chief Minister of Karnataka became a slang word for someone who is troublesome/ a nuisance. Maybe 1000 years from now when there is no India and no Industrial/digital civilisation of today, still Tamilians will be calling Kannadigas a funny name with no idea that this guy was a Chief Minister or that there existed the state of Karnataka).

Another thought that entered my mind was the illusion of permanence. Somehow people think they will be around forever. The world order they live in has a permanence different from that which existed before. Otherwise, why would anyone invest in building things so grand, so intricate. Maybe an efficient administrative system is way better at standing the test of time than the sturdiest buildings. Did any Emperor ever seriously believe that Rome could be invaded, sacked and plundered? It happened though. Several times through history. Did any Raya of Vijaynagara ever seriously believe his formidable capital city, with Tungabhadra flowing on one side and rugged hillocks with heavy fortifications on the other sides, would ever be breached. He was sure his palace would last 1000s of years. Instead it was razed to the ground and plundered. The second-most populous city in the world at that time became a city of ruins in the matter of weeks.

History as Events
Looking back, we might be terrified of what life was historically. Constant turbulence. Wars. Massacres, genocides. Uncertainty about life at every point of time. But this is a bias. When we read about history, we only read about "events". Otherwise it would get very boring, because the average person lived perhaps an average life, in several fundamental ways not too different from us, the children of the industrial and digital ages. The book I'm currently reading about the Vijayanagara kingdom talks endlessly of war and plunder and loot and massacre. But a step back shows that this was a small stretch of disputed land at the northern frontiers between Krishna and Tungabhadra. And massacres happened perhaps at one or two villages which were unfortunate enough to have enemy armies passing through, maybe once in a generation.

Slavery exists today. Genocides continue. War exists in so many parts of the world. But in general we have peace. I'm sure it was the same back there as well. When we look back on our current times, we will only read about major "events". Terrorist attacks, conflicts. So we will feel it is a time of great turmoil when really most of us are living dull, rather safe lives.

Morality
The last point I want to touch on is morality. We baulk at the morality of prior times and consider the morality to be less evolved or not as refined. Well, actually we condemn so much art and culture of the present day as immoral and hence "regressive". I completely disagree with this. The morals of a time vary with people and region. And they vary with time. If we think of a slave master from a 100 years back, we think of a very evil person. This is a projection of current-day morality on the past. If people from a 1000 years back and a 1000 years ahead, heck even 50 years back and 50 years ahead, were allowed to observe and judge a common person's actions today, they would certainly conclude that we are living in immoral times, even ordinary, well-meaning, law-abiding politically correct folk.

In general I think people make the same mistake with morality that many non-biologists (and some biologists) make with evolution - that the current is the "end-product" and the past was inferior. Homo Sapiens aren't superior or inferior to Neanderthals and Chimpanzees. Maybe when the anti-biotic resistant super-bug plague wipes out the population of highly sanitary human beings, we will see that we are far inferior to crocodiles, who shared the planet with dinosaurs and are sharing it with human beings today.

When we think of the life in Ancient Greece as we know of it today, it was full of sexual frolick and experimentation. This kind of a lifestyle is viewed as moral by some and immoral by others. But perhaps if there was New York Times then, it would view it as highly abhorrent and immoral while it would say it is completely left to individual freedom today. It is stupidity to not learn about the past, the stories, the legends, the happenings because of all the immorality and the sexism, the racism, the violence present in it. A person who calls Rama sexist is as stupid as a person who would put his wife through an Agni-Pariksha after a period of separation. And must we stop reading Jane Austen and Mark Twain?

* I have called it Part 1 because I plan to write a few more posts about history. Notice however, that I haven't said it is Part 1 in a 'N' part series. N can be 1 here as well, depending on how busy I am with research

** I don't want to be unnecessarily controversial, so let me also say I appreciate the nuances. There is no single Indian or Chinese or Islamic sphere of influence. Even these are layered, vary with time and region. And they haven't always been at each others necks. And they have so many internal squabbles also. They have heavily interacted and co-existed as well, while also been trying to outdo each other.

Jul 3, 2019

Secularism and Mysuru Dasara: Random Thoughts

One day, sitting in my uncle's house, I watched a very unique event. The Chief Minister of Karnataka Mr. Siddaramiah was doing a puja of the murthi of Chamundeshwari Devi of Mysuru. As he offered flowers to the murthi carried by Arjuna, the towering lead elephant of the procession for Mysuru Dasara, a chain of questions and thoughts started in my mind.

You would ask me why it is a unique event - the Chief Minister of Karnataka has been doing this for Dasara every year for decades and the tradition itself can be traced back to the Mysuru Kingdom and even the Karnataka empire, what is today known popularly as the Vijaynagara empire. Siddaramiah is an avowed atheist who is strongly against rituals and superstitious practices. His government passed what is popularly known as the "anti-superstition Bill" and he pointedly refused to invoke God's name while taking his oath in the Karnataka Assembly, preferring instead to swear on "truth". He once said he would be open to eating beef - an issue which mainstream Hinduism has consistently frowned upon and outright condemned for centuries.

Now, this person offering flowers to Devi Chamundeshwari is clearly not a Hindu devotee of the devi. So why is he doing it? Is Mysuru Dasara a secular event? An event does not become secular because people of all faiths participate in it. People of all religions often go to Ganesh Chaturthi or Durga Puja pandals. This doesn't make the celebration of Ganesh Chaturthi a secular event - it is a Hindu event, or an event of people who have Bhakti for Ganesha. The people attending perhaps aren't necessarily subscribers to the idea of God and the existence of Ganesha but merely attend because they live nearby or belong to the same community. Even then, there is some etiquette to be followed - no one, for example, may approach while wearing slippers. All the puja, the practises, the iconography is clearly of the Hindu God Ganesha.

Offering flowers to Devi Chamundeshwari is an avowedly Hindu practice - or at least avowedly a practice of Bhakts of Devi Chamundeshwari. Why is an atheist offering flowers to her? Well, because he is the head of the Karnataka government and it has been the tradition of decades, actually a few centuries, that the ruler of this region performs this puja. Before, it was the Mysuru Maharaja, then the baton was passed to the secular governments of Karnataka (formerly Mysore) state.

Does this mean the Mysuru Dasara has ceased to be a religious event? It would be absurd to suggest that showering of flowers on a deity is divorced from Hindu practices or forms of worship. It would be absurd to suggest that Chamundehwari Devi has been "secularised". She doesn't belong to any community, everyone is free to pray to her, but how can a state of the Union of India, whose constitution believes in "scientific temper"  and who pledges to stay equidistant from all religions and not facilitate the practice of any religion adopt this clearly religious practice and event as a "state festival"?

The state of Karnataka considers itself the inheritor of the legacy of the great kingdoms of this particular region. However, there is a distinction it draws. The piece of land does not define the history of Karnataka. It is the the Kannada language that defines Karnataka. So, even though the Cholas and the Marathas, Tamil and Marathi kingdoms respectively, ruled large parts of present-day Karnataka for a long time, their linguistic or cultural legacy is not something the state of Karnataka has inherited officially. The Vijaynagara empire widely patronised literature and poetry in Kannada, and hence we proudly say that we are inheritors of their grand heritage. Starting from the Gangas, the Satavahanas, Hoysalas, Chalukyas, Vijaynagara, Mysuru kingdoms and several others, these were all kingdoms who supported Kannada and gave us great monuments, feats of architecture and recently dams and industry. Their patronage led to some of the greatest Kannada literature ever written and also aided the Bhakti movement.

So when the Karnataka state believes it must carry forward the legacy of the Mysuru Maharajas, can it be selective in only choosing to inherit the language without the religion, the customs without the Bhakti? The Mysuru Maharajas were never secular - they were clear that they followed Hinduism even if they were tolerant and inclusive of all faiths. They conducted the Dasara celebrations as a purely religious event. How does the secular Karnataka government go about inheriting this? Must the religious meaning of this traditional event be completely stripped for the sake of the Karnataka government to celebrate this festival? Or can the Karnataka government momentarily defy the Constitution of India for 10 days a year as it organises a grand religious event? If the Mysuru King owned temples as they were patrons of the temple and had a family tradition where each family member dedicated his/her life to the service of this devi, can the secular Karnataka government inherit only the material wealth of the temple without being a patron of this temple, without enforcing that all in the Karnataka government must act in humble service of the Devi?

A word that often comes to the rescue here is "cultural". I believe this is a vacuous word - a word that means religious but can be used by secular folk to say that they're steering clear of religion since they're talking about this whole other thing called "culture". There is absolutely nothing irreligious about Chamundeshwari Devi. Whether you bow your head to her because your family forces you to or you believe she will give you her divine blessing, bowing before her is a religious act, no matter what high-level logic you are weighing in your mind while doing it. No matter what religious community you belong to. And here was Mr. Siddaramiah, a militant atheist one would say, doing it as a representative of the Karnataka government of the secular Union of India. He prayed for good rains and good prosperity in the state, he says.

A parallel might be drawn to the Kumbh Mela. I am not sure about the exact details of how the Kumbh Mela works, but if I understand it correctly, the mela itself is just a congregation and the individual aartis on the ghats are performed by individual temples. The government merely provides amenities such a accommodation, sanitation, etc. Perhaps the UP government does this viewing it as a tourism opportunity or as a necessity to prevent the spread of disease and maintain cleanliness. After all, you cannot simply ban people from congregating peacefully at one place. Either way, I am not here to defend expenditure on the Kumbh Mela. If the secular government of UP facilitates the religious aspects of the Kumbh, then I am opposed to this expenditure of public money.

I have no answer to this question and my concerns with this are two-fold.

As a citizen of India, I wish that the tax money paid by my parents and people I know, and the money that I will soon pay when I am earning in India, should be spent in accordance with the constitution. No matter the blessings what Devi Chamundeshwari may shower on the Karnataka government, this is a religious event and the Karnataka government has no business celebrating it and spending money on it. Why should my money go into the hands of a person with a faith that throwing flowers on a statue made of stone will somehow benefit them? What if I believe in a stone with a different shape? Or believe in no God?

As a Hindu and a Kannadiga who is proud of the legacy of the Mysuru Maharaja and the Vijaynagara Empire, I do not understand who a secular government is to interfere in a religious practice of my community and my Devi. That a person who is avowedly non-Hindu is given a chance to offer Puja from the pedestal where once a Maharaja who was a devotee and patron of Chamundehwari did it is an affront to my religion. It doesn't matter if the Chief Minister is HD Kumaraswamy, who is such a big devotee that he visits more temples after elections than before elections - he is representing a non-religious state that washes its hands off my religion - no bother, this staying away from religion is good - just allow my own community to celebrate it and organise it on our own.

Karnataka is a Hindu Rashtra in blatant disregard of the Indian constitution? Mysuru Dasara is a secular event in blatant disregard of its history? I am opposed to either being true, but one of them has to be true!

Thaayi Chamundeswari, neene heLbekamma! (Mother Chamundeswari, you only have to tell, mother!)